Welcome Our Team Contact Us Login

We can meet all of your insurance needs!

Your peace of mind is our priority

Mission Statement

New Casualty Insurance Specialists' mission is to give peace of mind to our customers. We pride ourselves in providing personalized service. Our agents take the time to understand each customer’s unique needs. We understand that policies are not one size fits all. Knowledge is the key to our expertise and ability to explain insurance in a simple and easy terms to guide insureds through claims, coverage and to provide tailored solutions for their individual needs. We take pride in our reputation for earning trust and being committed to our insureds. The foundation of our agency is honesty, reliability and integrity.

We strive to provide competitive pricing to our insureds, from reputable carriers without sacrificing coverage.

We conduct ourselves ethically and prioritize our client’s interest over our own financial gain. We believe your insurance is only as good as your agent and look forward to helping people meet their needs.

Protecting Futures

We have years of insurance experience helping clients prepare for the unknown.

Ask us about:

  • Homeowners
  • Auto
  • Boats, RV's, ATV's
  • Commercial & Business
    • Trucking
    • Garage & Dealers
    • Contractors
  • Bonds
  • Flood
  • Medicare Advantage Plans
  • Life Insurance

We can access many different insurance products so you can get the right one for you.

Assessing Need

Many financial experts will tell you some unforeseen events and a lack of the right kind of insurance can spell trouble quickly, especially for your business. Call us today, and we'll investigate your insurance risk and get you covered quickly at the right price.

Building Relationships

Everyone has different insurance needs. Call us today for a personalized business or individual assessment and find out how we can help protect your hard-earned assets.

Stacy Shuman - Agency Principal

Our agents have many years of insurance experience and each have our own areas of expertise, such as business, home owners, auto, and bonds.

Stacy S. began her career in insurance in April 1999 at a large Independent Agency specializing in Commercial Lines for businesses. In November of 2006, Stacy left that agency and formed a partnership with a personal lines agent. She spent 15 years growing an independent agency. In 2021 Stacy ended that partnership and started her own agency. Stacy is licensed in Property, Casualty, Life & Health and Holds a Surplus Lines Brokers License in Missouri and Kansas.

Amy Munger - Sales Agent

Amy has over 15 years insurance experience in Property & Casualty as well as Life & Health insurance, She also has two college degrees. She started her career as an agent with New Casualty Insurance Specialists LLC in February 2021.

Shelly Trauernicht - Agent / Commercial Lines

Shelly is a licensed agent and has 30 years of experience in the Auto Dealers Industry and has been with the NCIS for 3 years. She is a great asset to the agency and provides great knowledge and customer service with many of the markets we specialize in.

Tiffany Farr - Agent / Personal Lines

Tiffany is a licensed agent and has 12 plus years of experience in the insurance industry. She specializes in personal lines insurance and small commercial businesses. She provides great customer service and is a very detail oriented and a knowledgeable agent.

User Login

New Casualty Insurance Specialists

2400 Frederick Ave, Ste D

Saint Joseph, MO 64506-2760

(816) 623-6247